TOK Talk
  • TOK Talk Podcast
  • TOK Course
  • TOK concepts
  • TOK Exhibition Prompts
  • TOK Essay Posters
  • Contact
  • TOK Talk Podcast
  • TOK Course
  • TOK concepts
  • TOK Exhibition Prompts
  • TOK Essay Posters
  • Contact
TOK Talk

TOK Talk

​AN ORIGINAL PODCAST FOR TEACHERS, STUDENTS AND OTHER CURIOUS PEOPLE

Who owns knowledge?

6/3/2024

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · Who Owns Knowledge?
39 Prompt 29. Who owns knowledge?LY’s first response: “Those who study, those who learn, those who share” is not a bad start. I wish this were the world we lived in, but somehow I think the answer is far more complicated and often influenced by power (for good and for bad) more than we care to acknowledge.

What is ownership? That it ‘belongs’ to you? Can knowledge even be owned? 
Pioneers, inventors, artists, discoverers of new knowledge - do they own the knowledge they produce, create or discover? If whoever was first gets the credit, does that mean they own the knowledge? Once knowledge is shared, does it belong to other knowers that know it too? What knowledge belongs to the common good? Is knowing something the same as owning it? This discussion raised Issues of social responsibility that comes with creating and sharing (or not sharing) new knowledge.
After we think about the question: Who owns knowledge? So many other important questions get raised: What do we do with it? How do we care for it?  …LY asks but “so what”? We discussed the ways we value original ideas in different cultures. Zooming out, thinking about the implications of ownership and access, but also the responsibility for protection and upkeep that comes with ownership. Is the onus on the creator or user of knowledge? In a sense, are both ‘owners’? 
Links to dig deeper referenced in this talk:

  • Polio vaccine unpatented
  • Tang and Song Dynasty Artists  - CORRECTION - I was wrong about some details in our discussion - there are many individual artists known during the Song Dynasty (960–1279). What is interesting about it is how much their work built on tradition - shared knowledge of painting at the time seems to be of utmost importance.
  • Kaizen The act of always improving
​
Guests: Donna Gee, Liu Yu 
Music: Hilary Ng playing in the hallway at school


0 Comments

PROMPT 23. HOW IMPORTANT ARE MATERIAL TOOLS IN THE PRODUCTION OR ACQUISITION OF KNOWLEDGE?

2/16/2024

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · How important are Material Tools?
I met with Jon Rees, another TOK Teacher (as well as teacher of Human Technologies and IB English) ​here in Hong Kong, and we discussed TOK Exhibition Prompt 23: How important are material tools in the production or acquisition of knowledge? It was a fascinating discussion! Students, you need to be careful in this question about the difference between producing knowledge and producing things. While there is a connection (knowledge is needed to produce things), it is not an obvious connection so an exploration of the knowledge being produced (not just the thing) is required here. I think it would be very hard to argue that material tools (and conceptual tools by extension?) are not essential - and yet there’s room for exploration as you can hear from our conversation. I hope to talk with Mr. Rees again soon, as it was a very interesting and thought provoking conversation. 

Books & Resources that we referenced and discussed in relation to this talk:
  • ‘Sapiens’ by Yuval Noah Harari - this book is essentially an exploration of the role of material tools in the development of humankind, but is especially interesting when he talks about “fictional realities”.  For a quicker insight, watch this: Why humans run the world TED talk with Yuval Noah Harari ​
  • ‘Techno Feudalism’ by Yanis Varoufakis - he does a great job from a Marxist perspective explaining how his father taught him the concept of historical materialism, how technological development creates the tools/conditions for the advancement of the socio-cultural context. Then who controls the means of production, power/authority. 
  • ‘How to Understand E= MC2’ by Christophe Galfard
  • ‘The Sane Society’ by Eric Fromm - criticism of our focus on consumption in a nuclear age where we can annihilate ourselves 
  • ‘Song of the Cell’ by Siddhartha Mukherjee - deep exploration of our understanding of biology - the first chapters are specifically focused on development of the microscope and its influence on the entire field of microbiology and beyond
  • ‘Guns Germs Steel’ by Jared Diamond outlines the theory of geographic determinism, and thus the access to materials and the tools we can therefore make are everything in the development of humankind
  • ‘Knowledge Illusion’ by Steven Sloman and Philip Fernbach - the illusion of explanatory depth, mistaking shared knowledge for our own
  • Justice with Michael Sandel 
  • Little Museum of the World in Chai Wan - A time machine for building peace
  • ‘The Vanishing Face of Gaia’, by James Lovelock - essential wake-up call for humankind
  • ‘Donut Economics’ by Kate Raworth - a hopeful perspective! Nibbling away what we need (not beyond our planetary boundaries)

Guest: Jon Rees
Music from the ISF Student Brass Band playing outside the school gate one morning in December 2023

Thank you to Waffling Beans for letting us use your space to record!
0 Comments

Prompt 15: Constraints on Pursuit of Knowledge

5/12/2023

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · Constraints On Pursuit Of Knowledge
Recently I met with Naomi Chevannes who teaches Design Technology here in Hong Kong. We discussed TOK Exhibition Prompt 15: What constraints are there on the pursuit of knowledge? Breaking this down we discussed constraints such as access, tools, time, language, personal experience, motivation, perspectives, funding… We found possible divisions of these constraints such as inner and outer constraints, as well as an elegant distinction between constraints to the pursuit of knowledge which are within or without our control. We talked about knowledge as a buffet, and contrasted that with a famine (we may have gotten a little carried away with our food metaphor, as we were meeting just before lunch!! I really enjoyed this conversation, so thank you so much to Naomi for taking time out of a busy day to sit down and talk TOK with me. 
0 Comments

Prompt 4: On what grounds might we doubt a claim?

8/31/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · On What Grounds Might We Doubt A Claim?
To unravel this question, I met with Sarah Rodgers (DP Chemistry & MYP Science Teacher) & Alice Brookes (DP Bio & MYP Science Teacher). Together, we talk about a range of reasons we might doubt claims that are made about knowledge, and conversely what might make knowledge claims more trustworthy. We touch upon a variety of criteria, and discuss issues related to science, doubt in the time of Darwin when religion ran the world, the conflicting information about nutrition, as well as the current political climate in areas around the globe. It’s always fascinating to talk with people from different areas of the world, especially international teachers because we see things from both our own culture, our host culture, and sometimes a third global perspective as well. 

Are we immune from the challenge of doubting the norm? Should we really doubt everything? Should we question everything? Is breakfast really the most important meal of the day? These are important questions to consider and I hope you take some time to think about the things you take for granted and where you’ve developed “cognitive ease” around what you believe.

Cognitive Ease a 5 min youtube video summing up Daniel Kahneman’s Thinking Fast and Slow section on Cognitive Ease
​

Once again, thank you Bernard Wun for music to bring us in and out of today’s discussion.

0 Comments

Prompt 7: What are the implications of having or not having knowledge?

8/12/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · What Are The Implications of Having, or Not Having, Knowledge?
Today I sat down with Jim Faherty, an experienced University Guidance Counsellor here in Hong Kong to exchange views on Exhibition Prompt 7 What are the implications of having or not having knowledge? Because of his background in university applications and guidance, we discussed this question in relation to how having knowledge within this realm expands and helps to refine options for future choices in a young person's life. We go beyond this, and discuss the implications of having knowledge, one of those being the responsibility to share knowledge with others. We consider the reliability of sources, which is not only relevant to university choices but to all aspects of knowing about the world. We also explore what responsibility might come with having knowledge, and the relationship of money, power and knowledge.

We discuss the implications of not having knowledge as well again in light of having access to education (and therefore certain forms of knowledge) as well as the war in Ukraine and the race for a vaccine for Covid. We begin to think about knowledge as a resource, and only begin to ponder the problem of how we could better manage this resource on the internet. I hope you enjoy this episode and think again about the implications of having or not having knowledge.

Links:
Unifrog University guidance platform
Homo Deus by Yuval Noah Harari 
0 Comments

Prompt 6: How does the way we organise or classify knowledge affect what we know?

8/3/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · How Does The Way That We Organize Or Classify Knowledge Affect What We Know - 8:3:22, 16.02
Today I’m joined by Liu Yu, aka Mr. LY, teacher of Chinese Humanities and Assistant Principal at ISF Academy in HK. We discuss Exhibition Prompt 6: How does the way we organise or classify knowledge affect what we know? We explore Confucian values in China as a way of organising knowledge (and by extension society) within Chinese culture. We also consider language and culture as ways we organize knowledge, and explore how in our personal experiences we’ve been able to step outside our own individual cultures in order to understand more about the world. 
We also really get into the challenge of language as a way we know about the world, and the complexities of translation, as well as how having more varieties of language allows us to become more aware of the nuances of our experiences around us. There is still a lot more to discuss about this question, especially in the realms of art, science and humanities! 
Thanks again to Bernard Wun for the guitar that brings us in and out of this one! Links for further investigation: 
  • Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis ​“The limits of my language mean the limits of my world.” – Ludwig Wittgenstein
  • Shui Hu 水虎  (Water Margin)
  • All Men Are Brothers by Shi Nai'an, Luo Guanzhong, Pearl S. Buck
  • Sophie’s World by Jostein Gaarder. 
  • Permission to Feel by Marc Brackett
  • Mood Meter App
0 Comments

Prompt 5: What counts as good evidence for a claim?

6/26/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · Prompt 5 What Counts As Good Evidence For A Claim?
In this episode, I sat down with DP Design Teacher Donna Gee and DP Global Politics Teacher Bill Kyzner to discuss TOK Exhibition Prompt 5: What counts as good evidence for a claim? It really got me thinking about the significance of this question in my own personal knowledge about myself and the world, but also in a bigger sense about claims being made in today’s very heated political world. We stayed focused in this talk about evidence and claims within Design and Global Politics, but I cannot stop thinking about how perspectives play a very significant role in just how much evidence is enough to be “good” enough, and the implications this has on all kinds of knowledge communities. There really is so much more to be said about this prompt. I’m gearing up to do a reflection episode, so if you have comments or things you’d like to add, please send me a message via the contact page at www.TOKTalk.org.  

And thank you thank you thank you to Bernard Wun for his lovely guitar licks on this track!
0 Comments

Prompt 11: Can new knowledge change established values and beliefs?

6/1/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · Prompt 11 Can new knowledge change established values or beliefs?
I know this will likely bother anyone who is interested in order and logic, but I've decided to break the order of prompts so I can publish them as I record them. Turns out the most interesting topics to those around me are not necessarily in the order the IB has given them. Who knew? Anyway...

Today I’m joined by Theatre Teacher, Bob Scheer. We get together and discuss TOK Exhibition Prompt 11: Can new knowledge change established values and beliefs? Bob has also done the beautiful harmonies for music on today’s podcast, they’re really beautiful!

Links & fact checks:
History of Gender Pronouns
JK Rowling on gender and cancellation - a worthwhile read, worthy of questioning what you think 
Don’t Ask Don’t Tell
Don’t Say Gay
0 Comments

Prompt 2: Are some types of knowledge more useful than others?

5/13/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · Prompt 2 Is Some Knowledge More Useful Than Others?
This is the second episode in a series exploring the TOK Exhibition Prompts. Today I’m joined by Adam Walker, expert and teacher of Theatre. We get together and discuss TOK Exhibition Prompt 2: Are some types of knowledge more useful than others? 
We’re both teachers of the Arts, so our conversation focuses heavily around the Arts. It would be interesting to sit down with a physicist, architect, astronomer or statistician and have a similar conversation! 
Links for some of the theatre references discussed:
  • Verbatim Theatre (Focused on the company DV8)
  • Can I Live (discussed as Can I Change) 
  • Kae Tempest
  • Patsy Rosenburg
  • Kinky Boots
  • Babel
  • 10 billion - Katie Mitchell and Duncan Macmillan
  • Acid test – Peter Brook

Another thank you to Vyvienne Schapel for the quick little riffs taking us in and out of the podcast!
0 Comments

Prompt 1: What counts as knowledge

5/11/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · Prompt 1 What Counts As Knowledge?
This is the first in a series exploring the TOK Exhibition Prompts. In these episodes, I don't intend to answer the questions, but rather explore them and get you thinking. I hope you enjoy and find it stimulating!

To explore Prompt 1: What counts of knowledge, it was helpful to think about the following Types of Knowledge: 
  • Factual
  • Conceptual
  • Procedural
  • A Posteriori knowledge - from personal experiences
  • A Priori knowledge - from reason
  • Expert knowledge - deep knowledge from a discipline
  • Empirical Knowledge - from senses alone
  • Encoded Knowledge - knowledge encoded in symbols
  • Personal 
Thank you to Vyvienne Schapel for her quick piano keys today!
0 Comments

    Podcast
    Host &
    Creator 

    Emily Osann
    TOK Coordinator 
    Teacher of TOK & Visual Arts based in Hong Kong

    Archives

    October 2024
    August 2024
    June 2024
    February 2024
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    February 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    February 2021
    December 2020
    March 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018

    Categories

    All
    Arts
    Beauty
    Bias
    Bilingual Podcast
    Certainty
    Change
    Chinese Podcast
    Communication
    Culture
    Deontology
    Design
    Doubt
    Echo Chambers
    Education
    Ethics
    Evidence
    Explanations
    Fairness
    Faith
    History
    Human Sciences
    Identity
    Imagination
    Indigenous Societies
    Interpretation
    Intuition
    Language
    Literature
    Mathematics
    Methodology
    Models
    Mythology
    Natural Sciences
    Perspectives
    Politics
    Power
    Reason
    Religion
    Replicability
    Simplicification
    Social Media
    TCKs
    TOK Essay
    TOK Exhibition
    TOK Intro
    Tools
    Truth
    University
    Utilitarianism
    Utility
    Values And Beliefs
    Visual Representations
    What Is Knowledge?

original content Emily Osann © 2024