TOK Talk
  • TOK Talk Podcast
  • tok new course
  • TOK concepts
  • TOK Essay Posters
  • Contact
  • TOK Talk Podcast
  • tok new course
  • TOK concepts
  • TOK Essay Posters
  • Contact
TOK Talk

TOK Talk

​AN ORIGINAL PODCAST FOR TEACHERS, STUDENTS AND OTHER CURIOUS PEOPLE

不同文化,不同語言,不同的世界? Different culture, different language, different worlds?

2/13/2023

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · 不同文化,不同語言,不同的世界? Different culture, different language, different worlds?
​This is the first of a series of Bilingual TOK Talk Podcasts! Today I met with four Chinese speaking colleagues to discuss the question: 具有不同文化及語言背景的人們是否生活在不同的世界中? “Do people with different cultural or language backgrounds live in different worlds?” 

這一期的話題參與者來自中文組的三位同儕:劉宇老師、張瓊老師和白鷺老師。三位老師結合各自的親身經驗從多個角度分享了自己對於這一話題的認識,期間妙語連珠、精彩紛呈又發人深省。我個人在這次討論中也是受益良多,期待未來會有更多的中文老師參與到這個清談節目中。能夠完成這一話題的討論與後期製作,離不開Ms OSANN、王美婷老師、苗曉龍老師的大力支持。鞠躬、致謝。

Sun Laoshi led this conversation, and together we met with Liu Yu, Zhang Qiong Laoshi and Bai Laoshi. These teachers shared their understanding of this topic from multiple perspectives based on their own personal experience. Sun and I personally benefited a lot from this discussion, and I look forward to more Chinese teachers participating in this series in the future. 

I would especially like to thank Wang Mei Tyng Laoshi for the beautiful original musical composition especially prepared for this podcast.
0 Comments

Prompt 6: How does the way we organise or classify knowledge affect what we know?

8/3/2022

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · How Does The Way That We Organize Or Classify Knowledge Affect What We Know - 8:3:22, 16.02
Today I’m joined by Liu Yu, aka Mr. LY, teacher of Chinese Humanities and Assistant Principal at ISF Academy in HK. We discuss Exhibition Prompt 6: How does the way we organise or classify knowledge affect what we know? We explore Confucian values in China as a way of organising knowledge (and by extension society) within Chinese culture. We also consider language and culture as ways we organize knowledge, and explore how in our personal experiences we’ve been able to step outside our own individual cultures in order to understand more about the world. 
We also really get into the challenge of language as a way we know about the world, and the complexities of translation, as well as how having more varieties of language allows us to become more aware of the nuances of our experiences around us. There is still a lot more to discuss about this question, especially in the realms of art, science and humanities! 
Thanks again to Bernard Wun for the guitar that brings us in and out of this one! Links for further investigation: 
  • Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis ​“The limits of my language mean the limits of my world.” – Ludwig Wittgenstein
  • Shui Hu 水虎  (Water Margin)
  • All Men Are Brothers by Shi Nai'an, Luo Guanzhong, Pearl S. Buck
  • Sophie’s World by Jostein Gaarder. 
  • Permission to Feel by Marc Brackett
  • Mood Meter App
0 Comments

Do good explanations have to be true?

2/20/2021

0 Comments

 
TOK Talk · Episode 8 - Do good explanations have to be true?
Do good explanations have to be true?
Today’s topic is a previous TOK Essay title:  “Do good explanations have to be true?” To help me explore this question, I am joined by four fellow IB & TOK Teachers: Mr. Bill Kyzner representing Political Science, Mr. Francis Wynne, representing the Classics, including Latin Language & Greek Mythology, Mr. Jordan West-Pratt representing Natural Sciences, and today I’ll be representing the Arts.

Questions we discuss in relation to Natural Sciences, Political Science, Classics and the Arts:
  • What does each discipline seek to explain? What might a “good” explanation look like (as opposed to a “bad” one)?
  • Are there some explanations in your subject that are good but not necessarily true?
  • What is the role of truth in each discipline?

Three things that stand out to me after this conversation:
  1.  I was really struck by Mr. Wynne’s example of explanations in Greek Mythology that he argues are “good” and metaphorically true, but not literally true. I like this idea of different layers and kinds of truth.
  2. Mr. West-Pratt’s distinction of the role of truth in Natural Science - that truth in philosophy of science being different than the practice of science… For a practicing scientist, there is no distinction between a good explanation and a true explanation - they are one and the same. Whereas philosophers of science are not necessarily truth seekers but model builders.
  3. I was disturbed by the idea that truth may be irrelevant in Political Sciences. However, upon reflection, I think this is very much because of our overly liberal use of the word “truth” as a word to describe one’s understanding of reality in this discussion. I do still think there is room for further exploration of the role of truth, perhaps especially as it comes to description of facts and how this then translates into interpretations in different political lenses. Certainly, there is a danger as accepting anyone’s perspective as “subjective” truth, especially in today’s political climate.

Finally, I still am left wondering about the relationship of truth to the goodness of an explanation, and how that might differ depending on the audience of the explanation - who is the explanation for? what is its’ purpose? and does that determine what makes it good rather than its truth quality? There’s still much to be considered here. A title like this one seems so simple, and yet so complex once we start to unpack it.

No matter if you’re a TOK student, teacher or knowledge enthusiast, I hope that our discussion got you thinking about the relationship of good explanations and truth in your areas of interest or expertise. Tune in again next time for the next episode of TOK Talk.

Thank you to the random street performer in Shanghai for the intro and outro music.
0 Comments

Interview with IB Graduate

3/9/2019

0 Comments

 
In this episode, I sat down and talked with my oldest daughter, who graduated last May from an IB school in Shanghai and is now studying Art at Parsons in New York. We discussed her experience as an IB student and she shares her perspective about TOK, CAS and IB in general. She also shares some honest advice in general about getting through IB and applying for Universities, as well as her experience and challenges as a Third Culture Kid in University. We share some good laughs in this episode, and I hope that you enjoy it as much as we did. Credit to Leah Osann and Xoai David for their beautiful vocal harmony, and Xoai on the guitar in their interpretation of No Surrender by Bruce Springsteen (hope the Boss won’t mind…)
0 Comments

What's in a name?

10/19/2018

1 Comment

 
Welcome back for episode 2! In this episode I introduce my cohost, Hobbes and together we discuss the first way of knowing: Language. We ask and explore the questions: What's in a name? A word? How does language shape the way we think? Why does it matter?
1 Comment

    Podcast
    Host &
    Creator 

    Emily Osann
    TOK Coordinator, Teacher of TOK & Visual Arts based in Hong Kong

    Archives

    February 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    February 2021
    December 2020
    March 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018

    Categories

    All
    Arts
    Bias
    Certainty
    Change
    Deontology
    Doubt
    Echo Chambers
    Education
    Ethics
    Evidence
    Explanations
    Fairness
    Faith
    History
    Human Sciences
    Identity
    Imagination
    Indigenous Societies
    Interpretation
    Intuition
    Language
    Literature
    Mathematics
    Methodology
    Models
    Mythology
    Natural Sciences
    Perspectives
    Politics
    Power
    Reason
    Religion
    Replicability
    Simplicification
    Social Media
    TCKs
    TOK Essay
    TOK Exhibition
    TOK Intro
    Truth
    University
    Utilitarianism
    Utility
    Values And Beliefs
    Visual Representations
    What Is Knowledge?

original content E.Osann © 2022